Welcome to the collaboration review of The Promised Neverland episode 6, “311045” between this site (you do know that you’re on Crow’s World of Anime, don't you?) and Irina’s I Drink and Watch Anime. If you haven’t watched episode 6, you should probably do that before reading this review. Seriously.
Because there will be spoilers!
I’ll be in plain text and Irina will be in bold.
Both in font and in words...ok just in font.
This was an interesting episode. It actually disappointed me twice, but only because of my assumptions. In retrospect, it actually exceeded my expectations -- if that makes any sense. I guess I should expect something like that from a series that has made me trust a traitor and root against a mother figure. Not only that, but this episode started out with me thinking one of the characters was a complete blithering idiot and ended with me almost tearing up at the poignancy of the character’s motivations.
That’s a lot of work for a 25 minute episode!
Before we dive in, do you have any opening thoughts, Irina?
Well, none that won’t spoil anything so let’s just dig in. There’s plenty for us to chew on.
What happened to Don and Gilda? Were they turned into demon fast food? Capture from the Crunchyroll stream.
Do you remember the end of the previous episode? Don and Gilda had entered Isabella’s room ostensibly in search of clues, but really because Don was angry that Emma, Norman, and Ray were hiding something from him. That episode ended with the door creaking open. Were they about to be discovered? What would Momma do to them?
But it wasn’t Momma. It was Phil. He was playing hide and seek, and he needed someplace to hide. This was the first time the episode seemed to disappoint me. It made the ending of the previous episode feel almost contrived. Almost. Irina, did it seem that way to you?
To be honest, I fully expected it to be one of the kids. It was still daytime after all. We know Mom and Sister keep on the rounds usually during those hours.
But Phil...well let’s get back to Phil.
Can we wait a bit to talk about Phil? I’m on a roll about Don. I mean, did Don learn his lesson? Was he done flirting with death? No! This is where Don convinced me he was a blithering idiot. The first time he snuck into Momma’s room? I thought he was brash and reckless. I thought he was an idiot. But after narrowly averting disaster, with Gilda in tow, he did it again! So in my mind, he graduated to blithering. He pick-pocketed the key from Momma and snuck into the the secret compartment where Momma communicates with base.
At this point he’s a lost child. Emma, Ray and Norman have been super vague about the threat but insistent on the urgency. Of course he needs to know more. Besides, for him the stakes are still a vaguely ominous “I don’t know”. I can see him figuring it was worth it.
In retrospect, it's easy to see why Don would react the way he did -- what with Emma, Norman, and Ray playing everything so close to their vests! Well, "retrospect" for me. Irina saw it right away! Capture from the Crunchyroll stream.
You’re absolutely right, but before I fully admit it, and before we trace Don’t blithering-ness, I want to introduce you to my second disappointment: Emma’s fascination with bookplates. It turns out that Emma had noticed several of the books in their library had been donated by the same person, William Minerva, and that the bookplates were subtly different (actually, Phil was involved, but more on that later). All of his donated books had an owl within a circle, but Emma had noticed the circles were subtly different. They depicted Morse Code! There’s someone in the outside world who seems to be aware of their plight, and it seems like that person wanted to help the kids escape!
Maybe. If they interpreted the Morse Code right. The messages seemed to tell them to distrust the status quo; that they were on a dangerous farm. It seemed that someone was trying to warn them!
It wasn’t the Morse Code that disappointed me. Kids often learn it to communicate in ways that some adults won’t catch; that’s fun for kids! What disappointed me is that the kids might receive external aid, and I was looking forward to seeing them succeed on their own!
Irina, do you think I’m being unrealistic?
The way I see it it’s not so much help as hope (which may be the same thing at this point). The only thing they really got from it is a faint notion that humans *may* still live beyond the walls. This could still turn out to be a trap.
Whether it's a trap or not, someone's trying to send our heroes messages via Morse code. Capture from the Crunchyroll stream.
I wasn’t disappointed at all by this. This type of Scooby Doo antics is the stuff I live for. This said, the show continues its tradition of being almost ridiculously on the nose. An Owl for Minerva. Clues left behind by the goddess of strategic warfare…
This is where subtext rises to the level of straight forward script. Mind you, I have never reproached The Promise Neverland’s lack of delicacy. I’m impressed that the series continues to shock and captivate me in spite of being completely obvious in execution. That’s a tribute to timing, writing and characterization.
And for me, here’s where the episode started to turn things around (and I explain how I was wrong before and you were right!). Don and Gilda, using the pilfered key, found Momma’s secret room. They found Conny’s stuffed rabbit. They found toys the other kids were supposed to have taken with them when they had been "adopted." Both Don and Gilda knew what this meant: Momma was lying to them. And it was even worse; Emma, Norman, and Ray had been lying to them, too! At this point, I’m still thinking how idiotic Don was, leading Gilda into that room, but here the narrative clearly had other ideas.
It’s like the narrative knew what it was doing or something!
You know what struck me about that scene? There were a lot of toys, books and mementos there. A lot. Clean, well preserved, carefully lined up on shelves. Those could easily have been disposed of or if it was too much trouble, left in a neat heap or something. Why bother dusting them?
I'll never look at a stuffed bunny the same way again... Capture from the Crunchyroll stream.
The way I see it there are two ways to read a room like that.
Sentimentality and guilt is driving Momma to keep these souvenirs as a tribute to the lost children. Like an altar to the dead...OR
These are something like the trophies occasionally kept by serial killers. A way to mark her progress and accomplishments.
I’m not entirely sure which is worse.
The more I try to decide, the less certain I feel...
Don and Gilda aren’t stupid; they were following the clues with unfortunate speed. I say “unfortunate” because they didn’t take into account any wider considerations. But you know what? They’re kids. Of course they didn’t think strategically. I should not have expected otherwise. But I did underestimate Don. He had left the key out among the kids, knowing one of them would return it to Momma and perhaps hide what he'd done. It saved his life: Just as Momma was about to open the door and discover Don and Gilda, one of the kids bounded into the room and gave the key to her, saying he’d found it on the floor.
Talk about dodging a bullet! Momma was still suspicious, but it still gave Don and Gilda time to escape. They showed up in the lunchroom. But Ray? He asked the obvious question: Where had they been?
Don was smart enough to arrange for another kid to innocently return the key to Isabella. She didn't quite buy the explanation, though... Capture from the Crunchyroll stream.
They assembled after hours in the lunchroom, and Ray was furious that they had acted without thinking it through. He asked what if Momma had cameras or alarms? In that moment, I was right there egging Ray on! I was firmly of the mind that Don had been an idiot -- a blithering idiot -- for taking that risk, even though I had a lot more sympathy for him by now.
I was surprised Ray hadn’t realized that this was exactly what was going to happen. Obviously they were going to go straight for answers. And as you mentioned - they are 11.
Then the scene transformed itself into my favorite of the episode!
Before I dig into it, did you see this coming, Irina? This confrontation between Don and Emma, Norman, and Ray?
I knew a confrontation was coming. I think we all did. I did know THIS confrontation was coming...
I think I should have, if I’d had more faith in the story, or if I wasn’t so swept up in events that I wasn’t even trying to think of what was coming. If I’d had the faith the story has earned so far! What happened was that Don threw the gauntlet down. He tore through their lies, and Emma immediately apologized -- which only emboldened Don. So the three core group came clean.
Don didn’t just throw the gauntlet, he laid out their hypocrisy in no uncertain terms. He shamed them for their hubris in unilaterally anointing themselves saviors and keepers of the truth. He pointed out that they robbed him of the most important choice of his life by not giving him the information to make it. And he was perfectly right.
History is filled with atrocities committed for the greater good
Of course Don may have regretted finding everything out. This information rocked him.
Don demanded to know everything -- which is perfectly understandable. So was his reaction to the information... Capture from the Crunchyroll stream.
Well, they are just kids, and they haven’t learned their limitations yet. But you’ll notice I have to agree with you, you being right and all...
What was the effect of Emma, Norman, and Ray explaining the real threat? Don and Gilda were absolutely, completely terrified. I’ve become almost numb to the horror that this show represents. Don and Gilda, however, just now faced it, and it nearly crushed them. Don did with half of the males of his age would do: he punched Norman and Ray in the face (the other half would have run screaming from the room). He even threatened to punch Emma, but her expression broke his resolve.
And loosed the real issue.
He was crushed that they saw him as a burden; that they didn’t feel like they could rely on him. When they had originally confided in him, he was terrified. But their trust also gave him purpose. Now, he felt like he was not only second class to their intelligence. He felt like they had determined he was weak and in need of protection. What Emma, at least, had intended as kindness, had been a brutal cruelty.
I felt like Don was talking directly to me when he said, “We’re not as smart as you three. We’re not, but still… aren’t we family? Aren’t we siblings? I just want you to have a little faith in us!”
He was sobbing as he asked. I called Don an idiot, didn’t I? A blithering idiot, in fact. I was wrong. He was a child -- a child -- trying his best. And I judged him harshly.
What did you think of Emma’s reaction, Irina?
You know, I’m not a child at all but I’m not sure I would have done any better. As for Emma’s reaction… well.. It was par for the course.
Don was doing the best he could. He wasn't "blithering" at all. Capture from the Crunchyroll stream.
I think Emma is hanging on to desperate if vague notions of “right” and “family” - in fact I also think that actual word is what got to her and not the crushing realization that she may not be entitled to make this decision for all the children.
Emma is creating this persona and when it cracks, it’s going to be rough!
Don on the other hand was great.
What made it even worse was Don’s admission that he was in anguish because he couldn’t help Conny, or Gilda, or anyone. His breakdown was the emotional turning point of this episode. Emma blessed that interpretation when she just laid it all on the table and apologized for misjudging them. Norman did the same, prompting both Don and Gilda to say they were sorry for rushing into a bad decision on their own! Heck, even Ray apologized! It was a beautiful moment, and it served the narrative by reinforcing the conviction of all five of them to get through this alive.
Really, it had the opposite effect on me. Like oh yeah one is definitely gonna die SOON.
To be clear, I’m not saying it was the narrative’s conviction -- it’s the conviction of the characters! I have an increasing sense that the narrative has very different ideas...
The scene was sweet but the music did NOT work in my opinion. This is the first time I found it intrusive and it really dampened the mood for me.
That is unusual for this show, given how the music’s usually spot on.
After that emotional high point, the last three plot details almost seemed anticlimactic. Almost. But only at the time. Because in retrospect, they might change the show’s entire direction.
First, Norman and Ray have some up with a plan to distract Momma. Ray told Momma that the punch he received was from Norman, not from Don, and that they had fought over Norman’s plan to kill Momma -- using a hammer, herbicide, or other means. “Chemicals can be troublesome,” Momma said thoughtfully.
Second, Momma tells Ray that the next shipment will be in two months -- in January. Ray’s twelfth birthday.
The birthday where he’ll be shipped out.
Wait, wait wait! What happens on his 12th birthday? Capture from the Crunchyroll stream.
You and I have different notions of anticlimactic. Ray’s wry and just slightly sorrowful smile as he said, it’s finally my turn, will haunt me.
The harsh, almost menacing insistence that Emma and Norman spent every last second safe and comfortable no matter what. Even in his double play you could feel the edge in his voice. He may in fact care a lot more about them than either do for him.
He also seems to have started some preparations to help Emma and Norman even if he’s not around….
Well, I did say “almost seemed anticlimactic!” I was still digesting the emotional ramifications of the apology scene, so I might not have been thinking clearly the first time through.
The third thing that make change the direction happened when Norman was telling Emma, Don, and Gilda about the plan to keep Isabella/Mom out of the way. Then he starts talking about the plan to keep Sister Krone likewise occupied. However, he didn’t noticed that as they strolled through the woods, Krone was listening to them. She’d also seen their argument in the lunchroom last night -- complete with the punches. But instead of saying she’d turn them into Momma, what did she do?
She asked if they’d like to “join forces!”
This was one of those moments where I was overwhelmed with a sense that these poor kids were in way over their heads! What did you think, Irina?
I was fascinated. I really want to know where this is going. Krone is written almost as a caricature. Loud, exaggerated in all things, potentially annoying. Except that doesn’t fit at all with any of the writing in the show so far. And she survived. That means something, doesn’t it?
Sister Krone asked them to join forces? This seems like one of the most dangerous alliance like, ever! Capture from the Crunchyroll stream.
I think she might be using her bombastic personality to make people think she’s less capable than she really is. I expressed sympathy for her poor doll, but you know what? Taking your feelings out on an inanimate object so you can maintain your cool in public is a solid tactic.
Also remember way up there how I said we would get back to Phil. Little Phil that walked in on Don and Gilda at the worst possible moment. The same Phil that told Emma about the morse code in the books… Ray was five when he became an informant...Just saying, Phil’s name seems to come up a lot at opportune times.
Do you think Phil might be Ray’s protege? Looks like he might need one…
I have some random thoughts: They sure have no problem plotting out in the open, which is actually pretty smart. It’s a lot less suspicious than sneaking off somewhere! Also do you put bandages on bruises? On wounds, sure, but bruises? Seems useless.
Oh, and is it 2015? The copyright was 2015 but that would mean it was a book published that very year? That makes it much more likely that Minerva is around….Then again, that book didn’t have a message.
Does the lack of message itself constitute a message?
Also, I’m wondering if Minerva might be a demon who’s a private connoisseur -- a demon, not human at all. That’d be a bit of a downer…
That’s one of the things I like about this show. It’s hard at the time to know which detail is important! And for all I know, they’re all important!
And once again, we have to wait another week!
Reviews of the Other Episodes
- The Promised Neverland Episode 1 – 45,000,000$
- The Promised Neverland Episode 2: 131045
- The Promised Neverland Episode 3: 181045
- The Promised Neverland Episode 4: 291045
- The Promised Neverland Episode 5: 301045
- The Promised Neverland Episode 6: 311045
- The Promised Neverland Episode 7: 011145
- The Promised Neverland Episode 8: 021145
- The Promised Neverland Episode 9: 031145
- The Promised Neverland Episode 10: 130146
- The Promised Neverland Episode 11: 140146
- The Promised Neverland Episode 12: 150146